Is Baluchistan becoming another East Pakistan?

By Kuldip Nayar

By Kuldip NayarIslamabad faces today practically the same situation in Baluchistan as it did in East Pakistan. The former is as increasingly getting alienated from Pakistan as was Bangladesh in the midst of liberating itself. The army was supreme then as it is today in Baluchistan. Zulfikhar Ali Bhutto, then heading the Pakistan People Party (PPP), was backing the shocking methods of the army, no different from the ones adopted against Bangladesh.

Yet East Pakistan broke away from Pakistan and became a free independent state in December 1971. Baluchistan may go the same way if Islamabad does not wake up to the excesses committed in the province. Shooting down one’s own people for asking for a place in the sun is creating a cleavage which will be difficult to fill. After the experience of Bangladesh, Islamabad should have learnt the lesson.

A representative of Baloch National Movement met me more than a year ago at a conference in one of the South Asian countries. He said that if Baluchistan had a border with India, it would have broken away from Pakistan by this time and joined India. That is the reason why New Delhi is suspect in the eyes of Islamabad. His narration of cruelties perpetrated on the Baluchis had a familiar ring because I had heard the same thing in Dhaka after the Bangladesh liberation war. I was told how the cream of society was killed in cold blood.

I think President Asif Zardari made a right move last September when he offered apologies to Baluchis and promised to begin a new chapter. All the three armed groups – the Baloch Liberation Army, the Baloch Republic Army and the Baloch Liberation Front — had announced a ceasefire. But Zardari failed to take the corrective steps like withdrawing the security forces, tracing ‘missing’ people, releasing political prisoners and stopping the construction of cantonments in Baluchistan.

Zardari could not convince the army and intelligence agencies that Baluchistan could be won back, not through arm-twisting but through showing concern over the excesses by the security forces.

Conditions have further deteriorated in recent years. The result is that the standard of independence is flying at the many buildings in Quetta, Baluchistan’s capital. Pakistan national anthem is not being sung in schools. Only a few days ago there was violence when the security forces tried to stop functions held on the third death anniversary of Nawab Akbar Bugti.

True, he was killed in a military operation during President Parvez Musharraf’s regime. But the Zardari regime has not punished the killers to apply the balm on the Baluchi wounds. He has even failed to file a case against Musharraf for the ‘murder’ of Bugti. They who are turning their anger against Musharraf into anger against the government, headed by the PPP, would have felt a bit compensated.

Baluchistan can still be retrieved if steps are taken to make the Baluchis feel that they are masters of their own affairs. I recall when I met Bugti more than 35 years ago when he was Baluchistan’s governor and said repeatedly that Bhutto must decentralize power. This was a genuine demand. We talked for almost five hours and found that he was reconciled to Islamabad’s rule provided it transferred to Quetta all subjects except Defence, Foreign affairs and Communications. When I conveyed this to Bhutto during the meeting the following day, he said he had already a tape of our five-hour-long talk. This was the way of Bhutto’s functioning. Subsequently, he dismissed Bugti and went on to employ authoritarian ways to rule the country. Bhutto also did not concede the Baluchis’ demand for control over their natural resources. Nor did he enhance royalty on the gas from the fields in Baluchistan.

Islamabad continues to suppress the Baluchis in a ruthless manner. The security forces have killed three popular Baluch leaders, including Ghulam Mohhamed Baloch, chairman of the Baluch National Movement, in the last couple of weeks. The whisking of defiant popular workers remains unabated. These are the same methods which cost Pakistan its eastern wing.

True, Baluchistan does not have a charismatic leader like Sheikh Mujib-ur Rahman leading the movement for independence in East Pakistan. Still Bramdagh Bugti, a grandson of the slain Akbar Bugti, is a magnetic young man of 28 years. He is becoming the focus of independence movement. If Zardari were to take the matter in his own hand, he would be successful in solving the Baluchistan problem. Prime Minister Yousaf Raza Gilani is seen as the face of the army which has evoked so much alienation as it did in East Pakistan.

The tragedy is that the Punjab dominated Pakistan continues to be a unitary set up while its structure should be federal. It is difficult to say how the situation would develop in Baluchistan in the future. But one thing is sure that laying the blame on India or using more and more force will be counter productive.

The writer is a veteran Indian journalists and diplomat. He was also one-time member of Rajya Sabha, the upper house of the Indian parliament.

Source: Sunday Times


Filed under News

5 responses to “Is Baluchistan becoming another East Pakistan?

  1. Reblogged this on balochrightscouncil and commented:

  2. Qayyum Baloch

    No doubt, Mr. Nayar, has a great grip on the history and politics of S. Asia, particularly regarding Indo-Pak, ineer and outer socio-political contradictions which both of country are facing in form of Separatism. One thing not to be forgeted, That Balochistan is not like, Bengal,Assam, Mezoram, Nagaland or Estern Sekh Panjab….! Coz Baloch Have had a gorious History, An identified land by old and recent geographical refrence books which proved, (Balochistan) had been mentioned in the pages of the history. Mr. Nayar raised the point that Balochistan does not have a Charismatic figuer like S.Mujeeb-u- Rehamn…. so Surprizing…!!! Dear Mr. Nayar! Do Gandi Ji was more charismatic thn Mujeeb-u-Rehamn, Or Mandela could be copmpare with Mohmmad Ali Jinah…? Not never….coz every one has his/her own historic and cultural trend, growth, socio-political determinisim …. In our point of view as a Baloch we had a long list of the Baloch Leader who leaded the Baloch Nation and made it safe from the foriegn adventuriest. Today Baloch nation has much more skills, talants and vission accordingly to contamrory period. We Baloch Nation coollectively developed solid National thoughts, due to our these charsmatic Leaders like Mehrab Kahn,Akbar Khan, K.B Marri,Balaach Kahn,Brhumdag Khan, and Dr. Allaha Nazar. So thakns for your writtten words but may not be worry regarding Baloch Nation and Leadership.. Today all Baloch either in home or outside is palying its National role for a free home land and its due to these noble secrifices of Charismatic Baloch leader.
    Qayyum Baloch



  4. Asadullah Gichki (Bahrain)

    Mr.Nayar have got a very close eyes about the Balochistan Current situation, But I dont agree that Balochistan does not have a charismatic leader like Mujeeb-ur Rahman. We have great leaders like Nawab kair Baksh, Mari Brahadag Bughti And Harbiya Marri.and I do bleave that history can be repeated once again, the situation of the Balochistan is not In the hand of Islamabad.
    1971 History of Bangladesh will b Repeated soon

  5. Noutak Baloch

    I don’t agree with Kuldip Nayyar that “Balochistan
    does not have a charismatic leader like Mujeeb-ur Rahman.”

    No Sir, Balochistan has a chrismatic leader, Nawab
    Khair Bakhsh Marri who has a track record of struggle for independence and whose son Balach
    has been murdered by Pakistan army. Kuldeep Nayyar must visit and interview him to be enlightened about the situation in Balochistan.

    As far as Asif Ali is concerned, he is a puppet in
    the hands of Pakistan army. He did not learn the
    lessons from the murder of his father-in-law Z. A.
    Bhutto in the hands of the same army, ZAB brought for them billions of dollars from Libiya. Zardari’s wife Benazir Bhutto was murdered by the army and the forensic evidence was washed away within hours. In the beginning Zardari shouted few
    slogans of revenge but acquiesced later. Baloch
    don’t expect anything from Zardari. They are determined to fight for their freedom until their
    last breath.
    Noutak Baloch

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s